超越二元道德判断:在人工智能中建模伦理多元主义 / Beyond Binary Moral Judgment: Modeling Ethical Pluralism in AI
1️⃣ 一句话总结
本文提出一种将AI道德推理建模为概率分布的新框架,通过融合三种主流伦理理论(后果论、美德伦理、义务论)及其细分子类别,用堆叠集成学习方法实现88.89%的分类准确率,使AI能够像人类一样进行更全面、可解释的多元道德判断,而非简单的对错二分。
Critical decision-making in socially consequential spaces is increasingly involving AI systems at varying capacities. Yet, despite the ubiquity of autonomous systems, most approaches to handling autonomous moral decision-making resort to scalar or binary judgments. These methods are insufficient for acceptable moral reasoning, as they provide little explanation, leaving out imperative contextual and theoretical information that must be included to support accountability. For this, we propose a framework to model moral reasoning as a distribution over normative ethical theories or ethical pluralism. We introduce a normative ethics simplex that integrates these theories. A benchmark of 450 cases across 15 fine-grained subtheories was also prepared for the purposes of stacked ensemble learning. These cases describe ethical dilemmas in natural language and have associated extracted contextual features. The implementation of the simplex was achieved via a two-stream normative-semantic architecture. This is followed by the fusion of normative information and a sequential, stacking ensemble to learn the best fit of the three broad theories: consequentialism, virtue ethics, and deontology, and the 15 subcategories. Our experiments demonstrate that the integration of contextual and normative priors with the semantic embeddings significantly improves the performance of the classification, displaying an accuracy of 88.89%. We conducted ablation studies to show that structured ethical representations contribute beyond analogical reasoning, and the chosen stacking architecture gives the best results due to the gradual learning of granularity. Ethical pluralism is also analyzed through entropy, confidence, and visualization. Thus, modeling ethical pluralism as a probabilistic normative distribution supports human-like moral reasoning, ethical disagreement analysis, and future alignment in AI systems.
超越二元道德判断:在人工智能中建模伦理多元主义 / Beyond Binary Moral Judgment: Modeling Ethical Pluralism in AI
本文提出一种将AI道德推理建模为概率分布的新框架,通过融合三种主流伦理理论(后果论、美德伦理、义务论)及其细分子类别,用堆叠集成学习方法实现88.89%的分类准确率,使AI能够像人类一样进行更全面、可解释的多元道德判断,而非简单的对错二分。
源自 arXiv: 2605.28707